The 6th Annual
Symposium on Systems Research in the Arts

Baden-Baden-Germany

 

Music,
Environmental Design,
and the
Choreography of Space

 

Baden-Baden, Germany
July 29--
July 31,  2003

 


Session 1:  Music, Environmental Design and the Choreography of Space

 

Beyond Proportion: Structural Parallels between Architecture and Music

Professor Radoslav Zuk, McGill University, Canada

 

The fact that consonant musical intervals are based on specific whole number ratios of frequencies of sound has been recognized and visually demonstrated already in classical antiquity. Later, such ratios became the basis of Renaissance proportional theories. This has been well documented by Wittkower and more recently by Howard and Longair, but appears to be the only aspect of architecture whose relationship to music has been studied with serious attention. Other elements of music, such as rhythm or colour receive occasional mention, but usually in a most cursory sense or in reference to other disciplines. In this study key systems of architecture will be identified in an approximate relationship to the key elements of music. It will also be attempted to demonstrate that the creative structural coherence of such systems can offer a clue to the underlying environmental quality of significant works of architecture.

 

 

Constructions of Musical Spaces in Macau

Dr. Gertina J van Schalkwyk, University of Pretoria, South Africa

 

The purpose of my research was to explore the musical spaces in Macau and the different realities co-constructed by the peoples of this multi-cultural society.  In this paper, I will explain how relocating to Macau has offered me an entirely new experience of inter-subjective meaning-making, and I will describe some of my observations of the musical spaces co-constructed by the peoples in these parts – a mix of musical narratives exploding in a multi-dimensional and multi-cultural context where the gaming industry dominates, and where people are creating alternatives to the isolation of living in high-rise apartment blocks.

 

The “Open Form” in the Arts: Music, Literature, Visual Art

Dr. John Dack, Middlesex University, United Kingdom

 

The use of “open” or “variable” forms have preoccupied many artists since the beginning of the twentieth century and challenged the single trajectory of the art work. The use of such forms in music (the principal focus of my presentation) can be identified in the works of composers in the immediate post-war years. Particularly celebrated examples include the (unfinished) “Third Piano Sonata” by Pierre Boulez, “Scambi” by Henri Pousseur and “Klavierstück XI” by Karlheinz Stockhausen. However, the use of the term “open” disguises many underlying differences in approach and aesthetic attitudes. It could be argued that there are many types of “open” form each with its own inherent potential and tendency for development. My paper will concentrate on musical applications of the “open” form with reference to specific compositions such as “Scambi” and Henri Pousseur’s belief that the “open” form is a reflection of a model of society. I will also place the “open” form in historical context and discuss the connections with other art forms. For example, “openness” can be identified in works of literature such as “le Livre” by Stéphane Mallarmé, the “Cent mille milliards de poèmes” by Raymond Queneau. In addition, the mobiles of Alexander Calder can be considered to exemplify similar (though not identical) concerns. Thus, I intend to investigate not only the similarities but also the difference between the concepts of “openness” in these various art forms.

 

The Concept of Prolongation in Music and Poetry

Dr. Mine Dogantan Dack, Middlesex University, United Kingdom

One of the most important concepts employed in the analysis of tonal music is prolongation. This concept played a central role in the theories of Schenker, who believed that all forms in tonal music are ultimately derived from the prolongation of the consonant triad.  In this sense, prolongation is related to such concepts as stability, hierarchy, background/foreground, and structural unity. The concept itself raises important questions with respect to the nature of temporal experiences in music.  This paper applies the concept of prolongation to poetry by arguing that the functional distinction between first-person and third-person utterances can be employed to establish prolongational connections in verbal discourse.

 

 


Session 2:  Articulation of Space and Form

 

Prologue to Modern Architecture:  Theory of Chaos

Professor Jean P. Freeman, Marymount University, USA

 

Prologue to Modern Architecture: Theory of Chaos The science of chaos, which came into the forefront in the 1960s and 1970s, is the basis of this analysis on late modern architecture and design. Theories of chaos interrupted conventional scientific disciplines by attaching, unrelated types of wildness and irregularity, such as, global weather changes and the mathematical concept of fractals. It is highly mathematical in its origins, but references common scientific questions. These same concepts can be used to understand the architecture and design of such people as Zahad Hadid, Eisenman, LeCorbusier, Gehry and others. Some of their designs appear chaotic, random, erratic, however, there is order and pattern and a new disciple, which has evolved. This paper will address a way of understanding the complexities. There are theatricalization of the architectural experiences. The emergence of spaces that filter light, become barriers, address alternatives to the skin of the forms are all evident in the works of these designers.

 

Optimization Tools in Architecture-and Industrial Design--Form Finding Process

Paolo Caleo and Fiammetta Venuti,  Architects, Italy

 

In a very general manner, optimisation is the search of the best decision among a system of circumstances. Mathematically the problem corresponds to introduce a functional, called objective function, that measures the goodness of the decision, and a set of boundary conditions, described by inequalities, that determines the feasibility space (Comincioli 1995). Also in the field of Aeronautical Engineering and, more recently, of Civil Engineering the optimisation tools assume gradually increasing relief, because they allow a multidisciplinary and rigorous approach to design in a reduced time. Depending of the choice of design variable and objective function type, it is possible to distinguish three levels of engineering optimisation, in complexity order: i) size optimisation, ii) shape optimisation, iii) topological optimisation (Bletzinger, 2002). This memory describes the application of shape- and topological optimisation tools in the delicate phase of form finding. In particular, it will be shown how the application of the these tools, developed in the field of Engineering, represents especially in the fields of Architecture- and Industrial-design a useful aid in extending the complexity and finding out new forms from particular situations and boundary conditions.

 

Decorative Motifs of the Beijing Courtyard Houses: a Semiotic System of Confucian Values

Professor Jiang Lu, Eastern Michigan University, USA

 

The traditional Chinese dwellings are rich in decorative motifs. The courtyard houses in Beijing are no exception. The decorative motifs can be found everywhere from the foundation to the roof ridge, and they are implemented in many different forms including metal fittings, stone and brick carving, wood carving, and decorative painting. These motifs are in may different thematic categories that include geometric patterns, animals, plants, human figures, artifacts, and textual patterns. This study examines the decorative motifs in terms of their subject matters and symbolic meanings.  This study reveals that there are three major mechanisms through which symbolic meanings are assigned to decorative motifs. The first is the direct graphic depiction of symbolic images. The second is an ideographic implication in which symbolic objects are used to reveal the meanings indirectly through conventional interpretation and derivation. The third is phonetic association in which puns are made to convey the symbolic meaning. By decoding the decorative motifs, this study reveals that the symbolic meanings of the appealingly unrelated motifs of various categories are highly related with a central theme deeply rooted in the Chinese cultural tradition. The decorative motifs actually form a semiotic system highly synchronized in a loud chorus propagating the Confucian ideals of happy life: longevity, great number of sons, good official titles, and harmonious family ties. 

 

 

The Traditional Chinese Garden as an Experiential System

Dr. Jin Feng, Iowa State University, USA

 

The Traditional Chinese Garden as an Experiential System The spaces and scenic spots in traditional Chinese gardens were composed to produce wonderful experiences for people to stroll through. The wonders of a garden are revealed in carefully planned spatial sequences in which the visitor’s aesthetic enjoyment is enhanced. In this sense, the garden should be seen as a system in which individual nodes are linked in meaningful ways to form dramatic relationship between the nodes. The articulation of the relationship between nodes creates wonders in the visitor’s experience, comparable to the exciting enjoyment of a crescendo after a diminuendo in music. This study focuses on the experiential relationship between scenic nodes in a digitally reconstructed Chinese garden originally constructed in the early18th century, when the compositional theory of garden design was first formulated. This study explores the multiple possibilities of spatial sequences that a visitor may take to obtain different aesthetic experiences, and this study discovers that the garden under study, as a complex experiential system, indeed supports alternative routes and provides varied aesthetic experience. In this study, the digital virtual reality technology is used to allow the investigator to virtually explore the spaces and record the spatial sequences.

 

 


Session 3:  Sound, Symbols, and Systems

 

Unity in Twelve-Tone Music

Mr. Tuukka Ilomäki, Sibelius Academy, Finland

 

A composition needs to establish an equilibrium between unity and diversity. Passages with different characteristics provide diversity. Unity is created by the listener being able to recognize relations between the passages.  The difficulty of the recognition of row transformations has been argued to downgrade the viability of the twelve-tone technique as a compositional method. However, Schoenberg did not intend the row forms to be recognized and he deeply disliked the idea of “counting the tones”. Instead, twelve-tone technique can be used with several different strategies to reach Schoenberg's original goal: to guarantee unity in a composition.  An analysis of three pieces by Schoenberg, Webern and Berg exemplifies how unity can be achieved through the pitch-class succession, interval structure, and hexachord areas defined by a row. Consequently, recognition of the actual row forms on-the-fly is not necessary for the listener to appreciate the unity in a twelve-tone piece.

 

 

Some Aspects on Music Scripting Languages—
A Comparative Study of the Scripting Languages of Sibelius and ENP

Dr. Mikael Laurson and Mika Kuuskankare, Sibelius Academy, Finland

 

In this paper we examine and compare the scripting languages of two music notation programs, Sibelius and ENP. ENP is a music notation program that we have developed in order to meet the requirements of computer aided composition, music analysis and virtual instrument control. It is programmed in Lisp and OpenGL. Sibelius, on the other hand, is a widely used commercial notation program that runs on multiple platforms.  Scripting languages are programming languages that are usually weakly typed and interpreted rather than compiled. A scripting program, a script, is normally used to automate complex or advanced tasks within the program. In a music notation program one could typically use a script to apply an articulation pattern to a passage of music, to recalculate the enharmonic identity of selected notes, etc.  In ENP we use a constraint-based scripting language derived from PWConstraints. Our approach allows to define and identify complex musical patterns with the help of a pattern-matching syntax. This is an ability that cannot be found in other music scripting languages. Sibelius, in turn, allows the user to write scripts using the built-in scripting language called ManuScript. The ManuScript syntax resembles, in many aspects, Java and C++.  In our presentation we will introduce the basic concepts behind the two scripting languages. We also present and compare in detail a number of example scripts.

 

 

Sonic Constructs: Robotics and the Residue of Sound

Dr. Pedro Rebelo and Mr. Graham McAllister, Sonic Arts Research Centre, Queen's University,

Belfast, Northern Ireland

 

The instrument in music performance has an important role in defining much of the sonic constructs that allow for participation in a music culture. The instrument provides the most immediate vehicle for the sensory modalities of hearing, seeing and touching. As different materials in architectural space articulate the production of sensuality, in music performance this role is taken by the instrument. Recent technology facilitated and made widespread a desire for the design of new instruments and music making devices. Much of recent work in sound art and electronic music involves a rethinking of instrument design, be it by modifying an acoustic instrument, designing an electronic controller or developing a software environment.

 

Sonic Constructs is an interactive sound installation that uses Lego Mindstorm as semi-automata musical robots. In Sonic Constructs, two robotic devices move and interact while performing trajectories that produce sound as a by-product of the movement itself. Direction, speed, acceleration, position, scratching and collision become parameters of an environment for kinetic and acoustic participation. The surface on which the robots are placed functions as a sound stage as well as a platform for interaction. As Lego pieces collide, move and scratch, a complex sonic world is orchestrated. These, sometimes microscopic sonic events are brought to the foreground and are further manipulated with real-time spectral processes.

 

 


Session 4:  Music, Space, Culture and Expression

 

Whole Person/Whole Designing: Nurturing Whole Systems Thinking Through Storytelling

Professor Sheila Danko, Cornell University, USA

 

Whole Person/Whole Designing: Nurturing Whole Systems Thinking through Storytelling This presentation explores the emerging perspective of “whole systems design” (WSD) in relation to interior design education and leadership development. It positions design as a systemic change agent that impacts a continuum of experience from the individual, to the group, to the organization and ultimate to society. Systems theory, living systems and self-organizing systems are concepts that designers must use to underpin their creative products if designers are to play a leadership role in society. In his seminal book, The Fifth Discipline, Peter Senge argues that “leaders” must see themselves as “designers.” As design educators, we must help our students see themselves as not only artists, but as change agents and leaders. But how do we build that self-reflection into the creative design process? This presentation presents several studio interventions where narrative method or “storytelling” was used as a creative design method to build a deeply holistic, and humanistic perspective into the interior environments being designed. It also was used as a means of leadership development, helping students to reflect on their own roles as agents of change. Several creative outputs in the form of original stories will be shared which illustrate whole systems thinking through storytelling as well as student responses which reflect on narrative method as a tool for developing self-awareness and self in relation to society – two critical components of leadership development.

 

 

A Primary Source, Digital Collection of Images for Historic Research in Interior Design

Dr. George H. Olson and Dr. Margot Olson, Appalachian State University, USA

 

A prototype presentation, using historic kitchen images, both still and motion, from the American Memory Historical Collections (AMC) at the U. S. Library of Congress (LOC) will be demonstrated through use of a computerized graphics program (e.g., PowerPoint).  Many of the images in the collection are available for publication without necessity of copyright permissions.  The AMC includes historical documents, many of which are pictures, that date to the early 19th century.  The images include architecture, which is relevant for interior design, but also include historical documents such as wills and films, which document life styles.  The AMC provides images that take computerized graphic programs beyond a fancy version of overheads to a rich collection of visual images and sound.  Images from the American Memories Collections  can be downloaded from the web.

 

The Choreography of Interior Space:  The Design Work of Elsie de Wolfe

Professor Gillian Davies, Savannah School of Art and Design, USA

 

This paper examines early modernism as the presentation of a constructed vision which marginalized female designers, formulated particularly in relation to historically perceived gender identities. The illusion of autonomy in modernist theory conflicted with economic, sexual, and psychological meaning in interior design, space and place. Regarding the universalist architectural aesthetic of the European discourse of early modernist thought  Gender theory will be related to social roles and internal exchange amongst the modernist avant-garde.  The life and work of Elsie de Wolfe will be scrutinized in relation to the profession of interior design practice and the production and consumption of modernism. The nature of her clients, colleagues and critics at the time and subsequently will be examined to enable a number of crucial configurations, conjunctions and disjunctions to be interrogated within a clutch of parallel focuses which form a duality with the concept of feminine subjectivity. Oppositional paradigms of exteriority/interiority,  will be scrutinized with regard to paradigmatic modernist values. Foucault, and Derrida regard binary oppositions as essential constructors of difference and value in language, power and discourse, so a more sensitive approach to difference, not posited on binary opposites, will challenge the reductive divisions between public and private, male and female and the patriarchal divisiveness of the modernist ‘narrative’.

 

 


Session 5:  Music, Environment and Expression

                                      

“Liveness" in "Mediatized" Dance Performance—an Evolutionary and Semiotics Approach

Dr. Ivani Santana, Federal University of Bahia, Brazil and Dr. Fernando Iazzetta,

University of São Paulo, Brazil

 

In the information era dance performance is taken as a construct which results from the relationship between the biological and technological bodies. The idea of liveness can be understood as a process of communication in which these two bodies are no longer disengaged nor distinct. In this sense, the notion of liveness in mediatized performance acquires new implications, different from the ones proposed by different authors such as Peggy Phelan and Phillipe Auslander. This article addresses some issues related to the idea of liveness in mediatized dance performance, such as real time vs delayed time, real body vs virtual body. Taking the theories of Semiotics (C.S.Peirce), Evolution (R.Dawkins et al.) and some branches of Cognitive Sciences (G. Lakoff, M. Johnson et al.) as a point of departure we propose to discuss the role of technology in a mediatized culture as an agent which operates in the configuration of new instances of what can be understood as liveness.

 

Based on this conceptual framework we propose a reflection on the use of new technologies in dance and its implications for the establishment of new configurations in which body, dance, music, image and environment are used to challenge the dichotomies between mind/body, natural/artificial and real/virtual. For this purpose we present an analysis of two works - "Corpo Aberto" (Open Body - 2001) and "Pele" (Skin - 2002) created by the choreographer Ivani Santana in collaboration with the composer Fernando Iazzetta. These multimedia/dance works result from a partnership established between the two artists since 1996 and are focused on the critical exploration of the use of new media in the creative processes that are embodied in contemporary performances.

 

 

I-Circle:  A Live Spatial Collage

Ms. Hee-Seung Choi, Peabody Institute of Johns Hopkins University, USA

 

The work I wish to present is a multimedia project called "I-Circle" that involves music, video and a solo dancer. It grew out of my fascination with the human figure in motion and my desire to create living spatial collage.    The music uses synthesized sound and incorporates pop music elements. The video clips consist of kaleidoscopic images, images of the dancer, and those of my own drawings. Their unfolding is a reflection of the rhythm, phrasing, and the overall form of the music. The live dance movements are conceived as a spatial extension of what is shown on the video as a responsive reaction or in juxtaposition to it. The dancer uses an ocean drum as a prop, creating sound which also becomes an integral part of the music.   "I-Circle" just received its first performance at the Peabody Institute of Johns Hopkins University.

 

 

Niklas Luhmann's Ideas on System Research—a Chance for Contemporary Musicology?

Dr. Tatjana Böhme-Mehner, Universität Halle, Germany

 

The paper will deal with some results of my doctoral dissertation finished in 2003 about the chances of system research approaches by Niklas Luhmann in musicology. The Luhmannian theory will be introduced very shortly in general before some basic terms and ideas in the context of musicological research and theory will be discussed. As an example I would like to chose opera, because it offers the possibility to discus a complex phenomenon on a more or less theoretical level and in terms of analysis in the concrete opera. The Luhmannian approach – especially in some terms – is used as a model to explain some aspects in a certain way seen as problematic by other theories. So it offers interesting chances to explain certain problems in tradition, reception, interpretation and production. Some possible approaches for a musicological use of the Luhmannian system research will be demonstrated by some ideas about Richard Strauss’ “Der Rosenkavalier”. This opera is very often seen as a quite problematic step backwards after having written “Avantgarde-“Operas like “Salome” or “Elektra”. This step backwards can be explained as a necessary action to keep opera as a system more or less constant and to save it. On the other hand this opera offers a lot of aspects to demonstrate self-reference of the system opera as a genre within the story.